Of the numerous disasterpieces SEC basketball has produced in my lifetime, one that is certainly on the list is last year’s LSU. Starting out 12-1 with a pair of top 100 wins, there was reason to be intrigued by their future. Falling from #41 to #78 despite starting out 12-1, there was also reason to be a big seller of their future. 12-1 turned into 14-19 and dead last in the SEC in the blink of an eye. Turns out you can’t wholesale import Murray State’s good-but-not-great roster to the SEC and expect to immediately be a Tournament team.
In comparison, this year’s group is a pretty normal brand of middling SEC foe that will finish somewhere between 7-11 and 10-8. Matt McMahon, a fellow Oak Ridger, remade most of the team with a variety of transfers, both high-major role guys (Jordan Wright of Vanderbilt) and mid-major stars (Jalen Cook of Tulane, Will Baker of Nevada). The current starting lineup is three transfers, a true freshman, and one returner, a sophomore. Welcome to college hoops in 2024.
What this has produced is a rather schizophrenic grouping of results where LSU has two Quad 1 wins to go with two Quad 3/4 losses. The only other teams to complete that trifecta inside the NET top 100 are Florida Atlantic and, somehow, Appalachian State. I watched this team beat a bubblicious Wake Forest team on a neutral court exactly nine days after losing at home to Nicholls State. They’ve shot 3-19 and 14-26 from three in the same week.
This is not the least-consistent or most chaotic team Tennessee will play all year (hi Texas A&M) but it’s one of the more confusing. LSU’s an underdog in their next five and a favorite in the five after that; however those end up shaking out will probably give you a decent hint about how McMahon’s transfer-heavy strategy will work in the year(s) to come.
BEHIND THE WALL ($): A plea to Big Ed’s to open before 12 PM ET